CNET
Advertisement
Mobile Phones Digital Cameras Notebooks PC & Peripherals Handhelds Printers Home AV Videocams Music & Play
  
Brand
Price
Player Type
Interface
Storage type

Product Reviews : Music & Play : The shuffle-Tangent standoff
Email to a friend Printer friendly version Send us feedback

Round 2: Unraveling the features

Winner:
The Tangent


Tangent wins

Both the shuffle and the Tangent offer the same capacity selections of 512MB and 1GB and, in keeping with the Zen minimalism that Apple embodies, features are a rare luxury in the shuffle. In fact, the shuffle rather resembles a throwback to the earlier days of MP3 players. No display, no equalizers, no FM radio, and no recording of any kind. The Tangent, on the hand, tries to address these deficiencies with exactly what the shuffle lacks: Voice recording; FM radio; and even a bass enhancer.

The shuffle, however, has an ace up its sleeve--the iTunes music software which comes bundled free. With iTunes, options like the configurable autofill (which fills up the shuffle automatically with songs each time it's synced with the computer) and playlists are fully supported, while the Tangent still relies on a drag-and-drop interface. Yet the iTunes also represents a caveat for the shuffle: It is not possible to transfer songs into the shuffle without going through iTunes other than resorting to hacks.

We don't know about you, but we feel we would like to carry our features with us. This round goes decisively to the Tangent.



  Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4 Round 5 Round 6 Round 7
Super Tangent   x          
iPod shuffle x            

 Back to intro 
Go to the bouts:
Round 1: Getting Physical  
Round 6: Accessorizing the kit
Round 2: Unraveling the features
Round 7: Compatibility issues
Round 3: Ease of use
Round 4: Just performance
Round 5: How long you play?



Mobile Phones Digital Cameras Notebooks PC & Peripherals Handhelds Printers Home AV Videocams Music & Play
CNET