NUS/NTU notebook deals for 2007/08
By Darius Chang
29/07/2007
URL: http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/notebooks/0,39050495,62029343,00.htm
Editors' note : |
July 30  -Campus prices have been updated to include the 7 percent Goods and Services Tax.
July 29  -HP is offering a discount off its tablet PC for all tertiary students in Singapore. Note that the offer is not available at the University computer store. Click here for more details on how to obtain this laptop.
With tertiary institutes pushing for a paperless system, increasingly more educational material and administrative matters require students to be online. However, for most buying a notebook represents a significant investment. Though interest-free laptop loans are offered by the varsities, Singapore-based National University of Singapore (NUS) and Nanyang Technological University (NTU) have taken it further by offering big discounts on selected systems from some major vendors.
With so many choices available, just which laptop should you pick for your course? Should you get a light and portable solution, or will you need the added muscle of mainstream or even desktop replacement notebooks? Here are our recommendations based on your course of study.
Notebook buying guide
Top 5 notebooks for students
25 tips to buy the perfect notebook
Latest notebook prices
Note:
- This information is based
on notebook deals currently offered to the staff and students of National University of
Singapore (NUS) and Nanyang Technological University (NTU). However, conditions apply for those who have previously purchased notebooks under this scheme.
- Do note
that the models we reviewed may not have the exact same configurations
as the models being offered for campus use. For example, the NUS ThinkPad X61 featured has a 2.0GHz Core 2 Duo processor whereas the test unit we reviewed incorporated a 1.4GHz Core 2 Duo chip.
- Prices
include 7 percent GST and are correct as of July 25, 2007. Please check
with the respective campus notebook center for more information.
- Street prices are compared with the base model available to students.
Ultraportables (sub-2kg)
Ultraportables are the babies of the notebook world. Sacrificing the inclusion of integrated optical drives, ultraportables put a premium on mobility which allow them to be easily accessible anywhere. Size and battery life are the cornerstones in is class of mobiles.
Both ultraportables available for this academic year are business-oriented machines with strong security features and advanced physical protection. The ThinkPad X61 and Portege R500 have magnesium-alloy bodies which are stronger than plastic yet much lighter. The former's ThinkVantage platform and latter's EasyGuard technology optimizes and backup system operation.
The ThinkPad X61 has the advantage in price while possessing a more powerful Core 2 Duo processor. Compatible with a wide range of accessories and docking options, it remains one of the premium corporate systems in the market. However, the new Portege R500 is much lighter and slimmer than the ThinkPad, yet manages to incorporate an optical drive under its hood. Students who expect to perform calculation programs like MatLab should opt for the ThinkPad, while those in courses which involve PowerPoint presentations and piles of essays will find the Toshiba notebook more suited to their needs.
Click here for a feature comparison table.
|
|
 |
1. |
ThinkPad X61 (Core 2 Duo Processor T7300 2.0GHz, 2GB RAM)
CNET Asia rating: 8 out of 10
The good: Solid performance, thanks to the latest Core 2 Duo processor; extremely portable design; excellent keyboard; fingerprint reader; easy-to-use ThinkVantage utility; lengthy battery life with optional extended battery.
The bad: Lacks built-in optical drive; standard-aspect display feels outdated.
The bottom line: The ThinkPad X61s provides excellent dual-core performance in a lightweight, compact package that's still comfortable to use.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; external DVD writer; 12.1-inch display; Windows Vista Business; three-year international warranty; 1.9kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2007 Standard; notebook carrying case; USB optical mouse
Street price: S$3,059 (with 1GB RAM; 120GB HDD)
Review | See full specs | Rate this |
|
|
 |
2. |
Toshiba Portege R500 (Core 2 Duo ULV U7600 Processor 1.2GHz, 1.5GB RAM)
First take
The Portege R500 is Toshiba's newest premium notebook for the business crowd. Just how premium is it? Well, with a list price of S$3,999, this puts the R500 out of reach for all but the highest-level executive. However, for a dual-core 12.1-inch ultraportable complete with integrated optical drive, there are few which can compete in its class. The Sony Vaio G series may be slightly more affordable at S$3,799, but it has only a Core Solo processor. The HP Compaq 2510p comes closer with a Core 2 Duo chipset, but isn't as slim or light. Protected with Toshiba's EasyGuard features and possessing long battery life, the Portege R500 is great for students.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 1.2GHz processor; 1.5GB RAM; 120 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display; Windows Vista Business; three-year international warranty; 1.1kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2007 Standard; notebook carrying case; USB optical mouse; clip-on Toshiba USB Webcam (available till August 31, 2007) ; Toshiba USB 2GB flash memory (available till August 31, 2007); Garskin laptop skin (available till August 31, 2007)
First take | See full specs | Rate this |
Thin-and-lights (below 2.5kg)
Thin-and-light notebooks offer a nice compromise between performance and portability. Though not as small or light as ultraportables, the appeal of these systems is their integrated optical drives and full-power processors (as opposed to the energy-saving but slower ultra low-voltage chips).
Of the notebooks offered this semester year, the Acer TravelMate is the cheapest of the lot. Biometric fingerprint sensor aside, this model does not have many extras but is more than sufficient for most students who do not require strong graphics performance.
The MacBook and Fujitsu S6410 are larger 13.3-inch models for those who prefer larger screen estate. The Fujitsu model is lighter and has more connectivity options than the Apple machine, but when it comes to multimedia features the MacBook wins hands down with its iLife application suite and mini remote control.
Click here for a feature comparison table.
|
|
 |
1. |
Acer TravelMate 6292 (Core 2 Duo T7300 Processor 2.0GHz, 1GB RAM)
Outlook
A higher-end edition of the Acer 6291, this TravelMate bumps up the processing power and adds a biometric fingerprint sensor for added security. Possibly the first business-oriented notebook from the Taiwanese manufacturer, the Acer 6292 uses magnesium alloy for its top cover for added protection. However, for a 12.1-inch portable it's a little thick and heavy compared to other models in this category.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display; Windows Vista Business; one-year international, three-year on-campus warranty; 2.1kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2007 Standard; notebook carrying case; USB optical mouse
Street price: S$1,999 (with 1.8GHz Core 2 Duo processor)
See full specs | Rate this |
|
|
 |
2. |
Apple MacBook (Core 2 Duo T7400 processor 2.16GHz, 1GB, 13.3-inch TFT)
Outlook
Updated with a faster processor and larger memory from the previous incarnation, The Apple MacBook received high scores for its simple design and multimedia capabilities. However, some may find its glossy exterior a little high maintenance especially when moving around on campus.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.16GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 120 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 13.3-inch display; Mac OS X; three-year international warranty; 2.31kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2004 for Mac; 1GB iPod Shuffle
Street price: S$2,229 (excluding extra software)
See full specs | Rate this |
|
|
 |
3. |
Fujitsu LifeBook S6410U (Core 2 Duo T7300 Processor 2.0GHz, 2GB RAM)
Outlook
The LifeBook S6410U version offers a strong security suite with Core 2 Duo performance in a slim profile. Its battery life is not too spectacular, clocking in at 3 hours using the standard cell. However, its optical drive can be swapped with a second battery to ramp the runtime up to 4.2 hours. Based on the Centrino Pro platform, it has 1GB of Intel Turbo Memory to boost application speeds, though some reports have noted that the actual performance increase is minimal.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 13.3-inch display; Windows Vista Business; three-year international warranty; 2.08kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2007 Standard; notebook carrying case; USB optical mouse
Street price: S$3,188 (with 1GB RAM and 120GB HDD)
See full specs | Rate this |
Mainstream notebooks
Mainstream notebooks are large enough to incorporate high-end processor and graphics card, yet maintain a relatively portable form factor for trotting round the campus.
Both the MacBook Pro and Fujitsu E8410 are 15.4-inch models, though the former sprints ahead with its powerful Nvidia GeForce 8600M graphics chipset. The MacBook Pro appeals with its smooth aluminum body and Mac operating system, while those who believe in system security will appreciate the fingerprint sensor and TPM security chip on the Fujitsu.
However, strong battery life and superior physical protection of the ThinkPad T61 are a boon for those with slippery fingers and who always forget to charge before leaving the dorm. It's black Bento box body may not be as exciting and its integrated graphics also means no fragging during lesson time, but ThinkPads have been known to offer one of the best typing experience with its keyboard.
Click here for a feature comparison table.
|
|
 |
1. |
Apple MacBook Pro (Core 2 Duo T7400 processor 2.2GHz, 2GB, 15.4-inch TFT)
Outlook
Updated from the previous MacBook Pro configuration, this version hops on the Santa Rosa platform with a DirectX 10-compatible graphics card. It remains one of the more portable 15.4-inch notebooks around, and the fact that it can dual-boot with Windows is a major plus. However, it is a little costly considering it lacks common features such as a memory card reader and full-sized ExpressCard/54 slot (it uses the smaller ExpressCard/34 format).
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.2GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 120 HDD; 128MB Nvidia GeForce 8600M GT graphics card; DVD writer; 15.4-inch display; Mac OS X; three-year international warranty; 2.45kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2004 for Mac
Street price: S$3,452 (excluding extra software)
See full specs | Rate this |
|
|
 |
2. |
Fujitsu LifeBook E8410U (Core 2 Duo T7300 Processor 2.0GHz, 1GB RAM)
Outlook
The LifeBook E8410U descends from the E8210 and takes over the role as Fujitsu's flagship business model with a 15.4-inch display and Nvidia GeForce 8400M G discrete graphics card. This Centrino Pro system has a bright 300nits widescreen display and strong security features, with 1GB of Intel Turbo Memory installed.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 120 HDD; 374MB Nvidia GeForce 8400M G graphics card; DVD writer; 15.4-inch display; Windows Vista Business; three-year international warranty; 2.45kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2007 Standard; notebook carrying case; USB optical mouse
See full specs | Rate this |
|
|
 |
3. |
ThinkPad T61 (Core 2 Duo Processor T7300 2.0GHz, 2GB RAM)
CNET Asia rating: 7.6 out of 10
The good: Internal roll cage protects LCD; 802.11n Wi-Fi for faster wireless throughput; very small AC adapter adds little to overall travel weight; Intel's Active Management Technology provides remote support.
The bad: New Centrino technology doesn't offer outsized performance gains.
The bottom line: Lenovo's 14-inch ThinkPad T61 shaves a few millimeters off the company's more mainstream R-series laptops, but still boasts the same solid ThinkPad DNA along with IT-friendly features by way of Intel's new Centrino Pro platform.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 14.1-inch display; Windows Vista Business; three-year international warranty; 2.32kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2007 Standard; notebook carrying case; USB optical mouse
Street price: S$2,799 (with 1GB RAM and 120GB HDD)
Review | See full specs | Rate this |
Others
When it comes to raw power and performance, desktops replacements are the way to go. With its 17-inch display and high-end Nvidia GeForce video card, the 17-inch MacBook Pro offers superior performance for those in courses that require computer graphics coding and the diehard gamer. Moreover, tipping the scales at just over 3kg, it is also one of the more portable desktop replacements in the market.
Tablet PCs occupy a special niche among notebook users. Marketed as the electronic replacement for pen and paper, the pick-up rate had been rather slow due to its significantly higher cost.
Students who do a lot of design and drawing, however, will certainly appreciate the ability to sketch directly on the screen without having to mess with an external tablet peripheral.
|
|
 |
1. |
Apple MacBook Pro-Core 2 Duo (Core 2 Duo T7600 processor 2.4GHz, 2GB, 17-inch TFT)
Outlook
An update for Apple's 17-inch portable, the latest 17-inch MacBook Pro uses the more environmentally friendly (and less power-hungry) LED display which can be bumped up to an optional 1,920 x 1,200-pixel resolution for HD videos. Its Santa Rosa platform and DirectX 10-compatible graphics card make quick work of most common applications and even permit some heavy gaming.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.4GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; 256MB Nvidia GeForce 8600M GT graphics card; DVD writer; 17-inch display; Mac OS X; three-year international warranty; 3.08kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2004 for Mac
Street price: S$4,777 (excluding extra software)
See full specs | Rate this |
|
|
 |
2. |
Fujitsu LifeBook T4220 (Core 2 Duo T7300 Processor 2.0GHz, 1GB RAM)
Outlook
Updated from the LifeBook T4215 Tablet PC, the LifeBook T4220 is a 12.1-inch convertible tablet PC with a bi-directional digitizer screen that can rotate 180 degrees clockwise or counter-clockwise. It uses the Core 2 Duo platform with integrated Intel X3100 graphics solution and allows for a second bay battery to replace the integrated optical drive for longer uptime. It has a spill-resistant keyboard and a fingerprint sensor/TPM security chip combination for data protection.
Configuration: Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 120 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display; Windows Vista Business; three-year international warranty; 1.9kg
Extras: Adobe Creative Suite 3 Web Premium; Microsoft Office 2007 Standard; notebook carrying case
Street price: S$3,988 (with 2.2GHz Core 2 Duo processor)
See full specs | Rate this |
|
 |
3. |
HP Pavilion tx1222AU (AMD Athlon 64 X2 TK-53 Processor 1.7GHz, 1GB RAM)
First take
At first glance, the HP Pavilion tx1000 introduced at the company's launch in Korea looks like a smaller 12.1-inch version of the popular Pavilion dv2000-series notebooks. However, upon closer inspection, the screen swivels to disclose its true identity as a convertible tablet. As the first tablet PC in the Pavilion series, the tx1000 retains the fun aspects of its lineage while combining the serious work ethics of a portable.
Configuration: AMD Athlon X2 1.7GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 160 HDD; Nvidia GeForce Go 6150 graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display; Windows Vista Home Premium Edition; three-year international warranty; 2.0kg
Extras: To be announced
First take | See full specs | Rate this |
Which is the best deal?
Forget about performance. Who cares about portability? What you want to do is to squeeze as much savings out of these already discounted portables as you can. Don't worry about us calling you cheap, because we'd probably do the same thing in your shoes.
Note: Street prices do not take in consideration extras like software or peripherals.
|
Configuration |
Street Price |
Campus Price |
Savings |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 120 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display |
S$3,988 (with 2.2GHz Core 2 Duo processor) |
|
34.9% |
|
AMD Athlon X2 1.7GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 160 HDD; Nvidia GeForce Go 6150 graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display |
|
|
30.2% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 13.3-inch display |
S$3,188 (with 1GB RAM and 120GB HDD) |
|
29.6% |
|
Core 2 Duo 1.2GHz processor; 1.5GB RAM; 120 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display |
|
|
25.4% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 120 HDD; 374MB Nvidia GeForce 8400M G graphics card; DVD writer; 15.4-inch display |
|
|
22.4% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; external DVD writer; 12.1-inch display |
S$3,059 (with 1GB RAM; 120GB HDD) |
|
19.7% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 14.1-inch display |
S$2,799 (with 1GB RAM and 120GB HDD) |
|
15.9% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.0GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 160 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 12.1-inch display |
S$1,999 (with 1.8GHz Core 2 Duo processor) |
|
9.1% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.4GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 160 HDD; 256MB Nvidia GeForce 8600M GT graphics card; DVD writer; 17-inch display |
S$4,777 (excluding extra software) |
|
1.7% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.2GHz processor; 2GB RAM; 120 HDD; 128MB Nvidia GeForce 8600M GT graphics card; DVD writer; 15.4-inch display |
S$3,452 (excluding extra software) |
|
-4.0% |
|
Core 2 Duo 2.16GHz processor; 1GB RAM; 120 HDD; integrated graphics card; DVD writer; 13.3-inch display |
S$2,229 (excluding extra software and free iPod Shuffle) |
|
-17.4% |
Which notebook is for me?
Degree in Arts and Social Sciences/Business/Law
Writing tons of essay is your forte, which is why you shouldn't burden yourself with heavy portables that take up loads of bag space. The ultraportables like the ThinkPad X61 and Toshiba Portege R500 fit your needs perfectly. With its low-power processor, built-in optical drive and exceptionally slim and light body, the Toshiba R500 will look classy in your bag. However, if you need more processing oomph for graphics editing and presentations, you'll have to sacrifice weight and the built-in DVD drive for the ThinkPad X61.
Degree in Science
Barring the occasional cross-faculty module, science students are not expected to run around gathering polls, conducting interviews, etc., which those in the soft sciences are expected to do. Hence, they can afford the luxury of thin-and-light notebooks with larger screens at cheaper prices. The full-powered processor also helps when computational programs such as MatLab are required.
Degree in Design and Environment/Engineering
Drawing on pen and paper is just so 1990s. Using a tablet PC, you can sketch directly on a laptop and save a few trees in the process. But if touchscreen doesn't appeal to you, then the discrete graphics cards in mainstream laptops like the 15-inch MacBook Pro and Fujitsu LifeBook E8410 will make your AutoCad experience so much smoother.
Degree in Computing
Power, power and more power. With 3D animation being such a hot industry right now, more than a few modules will likely need superior graphics performance in the 17-inch MacBook Pro. No problem if your course requires you to code in Windows, as the machine can be dual-booted with the Microsoft platform. Oh, and it doesn't hurt that you can also do some serious fragging after exams as well.
|