Advertisement

--------------------------------------------------------------
This story was printed from CNET Asia.
--------------------------------------------------------------
CNET's notebook buying guide

By CNET staff
25/09/2006
URL: http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/notebooks/0,39050495,39172661,00.htm

What kind of laptop is right for me?

To choose the right notebook--one with the right set of features at the right price--you'll need to figure out how you'll want to use your machine. Match your needs to one of these user profiles to get started.

Find out more about:
Home userHome user  Home user
Home users are increasingly turning to notebooks as second or third PCs for the home. Notebooks can offer similar performance and features to those of a desktop PC, but they can be easily moved from room to room. Two types of notebooks are suitable for home users: mainstream notebooks and desktop replacements.

 KEY FEATURES:
Processor: AMD Turion, Intel Core Duo, or Intel Core 2 Duo
At least 512MB of memory
Large hard drive for storing digital photos and video
14-inch display or larger
Fixed or swappable DVD/CDRW combo drives
External keyboard and mouse
Ethernet and wireless networking
Microsoft Windows XP Home
Microsoft Works Suite
StudentStudent  Student
Students and others on a tight budget should look for a laptop that delivers the most bang for the buck. In particular, students need a notebook that is small and light enough to lug back and forth across campus but rugged enough to withstand bouncing around in a backpack.

 KEY FEATURES:
Processor: AMD Turion, Intel Core Duo, or Intel Core 2 Duo
At least 512MB of memory
Big hard drive to hold all those MP3s
DVD/CDRW combo drive for burning audio CDs
Wired and wireless networking for network-equipped classrooms and dorm rooms
Microsoft Windows XP Home or Apple Mac OS X
Microsoft Office XP Student & Teacher Edition or Office X for Mac OS
Frequent flierFrequent flier  Frequent flier
If you spend a lot of time on the road, size and weight are the two most critical factors in choosing a new notebook--even if it means sacrificing a little on performance and features. The smallest and lightest notebooks, ultraportables, weigh less than 1.8kg and are no thicker than a spiral-bound notebook.

 KEY FEATURES:
Processor: AMD Turion, Intel Core Duo, or Intel Core 2 Duo
At least 512MB of memory
A 13.3-inch display or smaller
Wired and wireless networking
Extended battery for those cross-country flights
Media slice or external USB DVD/CDRW combo drive
Port replicator for the desk
Microsoft Windows XP Professional or Tablet Edition
Microsoft Office XP Professional Edition
Business power userBusiness power user  Business power user
If you rely on the same notebook at work, at home, and on the road, you need a well-balanced system. And it has to deliver the performance to keep up with a wide range of applications. A thin-and-light is just the ticket.

 KEY FEATURES:
Processor: AMD Turion or Intel Core 2 Duo
At least 512MB of memory
Midsized hard drive
A 14-inch or 15.4-inch display
Dual-layer DVD burner
Wired and wireless networking
Extra battery
Microsoft Windows XP Professional, Microsoft Media Center Edition
Microsoft Office XP Professional
Multimedia author or gamerMultimedia author or gamer  Multimedia author or gamer
If you demand more from a notebook, you'll need a true desktop replacement. Whether you're designing a Web site, editing home movies, or mowing down aliens, your notebook will demand a powerful processor, plenty of memory, great graphics, and a healthy hard drive.

 KEY FEATURES:
Processor: AMD Turion or Intel Core 2 Duo
1GB to 2GB of memory
A 15.4-inch display or larger
Advanced graphics card with 128MB or 256MB of its own memory
The largest and fastest hard drive available
Dual-layer DVD burner
Multimedia connectors, such as S-Video, DVI, FireWire, S/PDIF
External keyboard and mouse
Microsoft Windows XP Home or Professional, Microsoft Media Center Edition, or Apple Mac OS X

What kind of laptop is right for me?

Laptops come in all kinds of shapes and sizes, each with its own set of pros and cons. While the smallest laptops are the most portable (and often the coolest-looking), they also have smaller keyboards and displays, fewer features, and slower performance than their bulkier brethren. Conversely, more full-featured laptops are generally more difficult to carry and take up more space on your desk and in your bag.

Until they make the perfect laptop, you'll have to sacrifice something, so think about what's most important to you--computing power, a complete set of features, long battery life, good looks, a small form factor, or a low price. Take a look below to learn more about what each type of laptop has to offer.


Find out more about:


Sizes: Ultraportable | Thin-and-light | Midsize | Desktop replacement | Tablet PC


UltraportablesUltraportable
The smallest, most lightweight laptops are called ultraportables. Their compact form factor is crucial for people who need to have their PC with them all the time, especially frequent business travelers. What you gain in portability, however, you usually give up in terms of weaker performance, smaller keyboards and displays, and fewer features. And what's more, ultraportable laptops almost always carry a premium price tag. Still, a compact, lightweight profile can make all the difference if you spend a lot of time on the road.

Ultraportables

• Weight: 1.8kg or less
•  Size: Less than 2.5mm thick
•  Display: Smaller than 14 inches (diagonal)
• Processor: Slower, low-voltage mobile processors; some dual-core CPUs
• Features: Fewer ports and connections; 30GB to 60GB hard drive
• Networking: LAN, modem, WiFi, Bluetooth (optional), cellular (optional)
• Other things to note: Small keyboard and touchpad; may lack an internal optical drive

Thin-and-lightsThin-and-light
A thin-and-light offers the optimal combination of portability, performance, features, and cost. Power-tuned mobile processors deliver enough power to keep you working smoothly, and unlike ultraportables, most thin-and-lights have a more reasonably sized keyboard and display, a larger hard drive, and a built-in optical drive. Yes, they're more expensive than slightly larger, heavier midsize laptops, but if you need maximum productivity in a portable package, this is the best choice.

Thin-and-lights

•  Weight: 1.8 to 2.5kg
•  Size: Approximately 2.5mm thick
• Display: 12 to 14 inches (diagonal), possibly widescreen
• Processor: Midrange-to-fast mobile processors; many dual-core options
•  Features: Most ports and connections; 60GB to 100GB hard drive; optical drive
• Networking: LAN, modem, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth (optional), WWAN (optional)
• Other things to note: Small keyboard and touchpad

Midsize notebooksMidsize (a.k.a. mainstream)
Not all midsize laptops are inexpensive, but most inexpensive laptops are midsize. Why? Whereas a desktop replacement is designed to deliver high performance and a thin-and-light is optimized for portability, the typical midsize laptop isn't specialized. Rather, a midsize laptop gives you everything you need for basic computing (word processing, storing digital photos), home entertainment (burning CDs, watching DVDs), and online communication (email and Web surfing). Slightly smaller than desktop replacements and with limited battery life, midsize laptops aren't particularly well suited for regular travel.

Midsize

•  Weight: 2.5 to 3.2kg
•  Size: More than 2.5mm thick
•  Display: 14 to 15.4 inches (diagonal), possibly widescreen
• Processor: Slow/budget AMD Sempron or Intel Celeron, midrange AMD Turion 64 or Intel Pentium, or fast Turion 64 X2 or Core Duo processors
• Features: Most ports and connections; 40GB to 80GB hard drive; DVD burner; memory card reader; decent software package
• Networking: LAN, modem, WiFi
• Other things to note: May be less attractively-designed; may suffer from mediocre performance and battery life

Desktop replacementsDesktop replacement
The largest and heaviest type of laptop, desktop replacements are designed to deliver the power and features you'd get from a desktop PC. Too bulky for anything but room-to-room travel within a house or an office, desktop replacements typically offer the best performance, the largest screens and keyboards, and the most complete set of features available on a laptop. Popular among home and business users, these systems can deliver enough computing muscle for serious gaming, multimedia authoring, and even high-level digital audio and video work.

Desktop replacements

•  Weight: 3.2kg or more
•  Size: Over 2.5mm thick
•  Display: 17 to 20 inches (diagonal)
• Processor: Fast mobile processors; usually dual core
• Features: Wide array of ports and connections; 60GB to 240GB hard drive space; double-layer DVD burner
• Networking: LAN, modem, Wi-Fi, Bluetooth (optional)
• Other things to note: Large keyboard, separate number pad, large touch pad; batteries not designed for lengthy mobile use.

Tablet PCsTablet PC
Usually comparable in size and weight to ultraportable or thin-and-light laptops, tablets let you take handwritten notes and navigate menus, documents, and Web pages using a stylus directly on the screen. The most common type is the convertible tablet, which looks much like traditional a laptop but has a display that swivels 180 degrees and folds flat over the keyboard. (Some manufacturers are incorporating this type of tablet functionality into larger midsize and thin-and-light laptops.) Slate tablets, on the other hand, lack keyboards--they're all screen. The smallest tablets, ultramobile PCs, bridge the gap between PDA and ultraportable, with 7-inch touch-screen displays and enhanced media player features. Once only the tool of specialized industries, tablets are gaining a wider audience, thanks to their portability, flexibility, and wow factor.

Tablet PCs

•  Weight: Usually 1.8kg or less, with some slates weighing as little as 1kg; some larger laptops incorporate tablet functionality
•  Size: Less than 2.5mm thick
•  Display: 12-inch (diagonal) or smaller digitized display
• Processor: Moderate mobile processors
• Features: Fewer ports and connections; 30GB to 60GB hard drive
• Networking: LAN, modem, WiFi, Bluetooth (optional)
• Other things to note: Microsoft XP Tablet Edition OS; handwriting recognition software

Notebook specs vary widely depending on what you need to get out of your portable computer. Manufacturers make tradeoffs--slower processors allow for smaller batteries, for instance--so it's important to know what you'll have to sacrifice to get the notebook of your dreams. Many vendors offer configuration choices when you buy your notebook. We've broken out the most important specs so that you understand your choices.

Find out more about:

Options: Chipset | Processor | Memory | Display size


What are my processor, screen, and memory options?

ProcessorChipset

Sometimes referred to as the CPU, or central processing unit, the processor is the brains of the computer. It's the most important chip in a notebook, and it has power-management features that extend battery life. Notebooks use a variety of processor types depending on their focus. The chart below shows all of the laptop processors currently available from AMD and Intel; in practice, most manufacturers offer laptop configurations using only a handful of the most recent chips.

Note that this chart shows only the relative performance and battery life of each processor within the product lines of AMD and Intel. The rankings are not based on independent test results, and the actual performance and battery life of a laptop will depend on many factors, including the display, the size of the battery, and the optimizations made by the manufacturer. The only way to accurately gauge performance and battery life is through hands-on reviews based on objective labs tests.

Generation
Mainboard
Wi-Fi
Processor
First generation Intel 855 chipset Intel Pro/Wireless 2100b or Intel Pro/Wireless 2200b/g Pentium M (Banias) - 400MHz FSB
Second generation (Sonoma) Intel 915 chipset Intel Pro/Wireless 2200b/g or Intel Pro/Wireless 2915a/b/g Pentium M (Dothan) - 533MHz FSB
Third generation (Napa) Intel 945 chipset Intel Pro/Wireless 2915a/b/g or Intel Pro/Wireless 3945a/b/g Core Duo/Core Solo (Yonah) - 667MHz FSB


ProcessorProcessor

Sometimes referred to as the CPU, or central processing unit, the processor is the brains of the computer. It's the most important chip in a notebook, and it has power-management features that extend battery life. Laptops use a variety of processor types depending on their focus. We've explained each in the chart below:

Processor
Notebook type
Performance
Battery life
Price
AMD Athlon 64 for DTR Desktop replacement
AMD Turion 64 All types
AMD Turion 64 X2 Dual Core Thin-and-light
Intel Celeron M Ultraportable, thin-and-light and mainstream
Intel Core 2 Duo All types
Intel Core Duo All types
Intel Core Solo Ultraportable and thin-and-light
Intel Pentium M Ultraportable, thin-and-light and mainstream
Mobile AMD Athlon 64 Mainstream and desktop replacement
Mobile AMD Sempron Ultraportable, thin-and-light and mainstream
Mobile Intel Pentium 4 All types
Mobile Intel Pentium 4 with HT All types
Memory Memory
Every computer comes with a certain amount of physical memory, usually referred to as main memory or RAM (random-access memory). Computers store currently running applications and data in this area. To find out how much memory you'll need, take into account your operating system and the applications that you plan to use. A general rule of thumb: You'll want 512MB for Windows XP or Mac OS X and 256MB for all other Windows and Mac operating systems. If you hope to run Windows Vista when it's released in early 2007, you'll need at least 512MB, preferably 1GB.

If you're planning to hang on to your notebook for a long time, look for a laptop with easy-to-access memory slots, as memory is typically one of the first specs you'll want to upgrade.
Display sizeDisplay size
Unlike traditional desktop CRT (cathode-ray tube) monitors, notebooks ship with thin, liquid-crystal displays (LCDs). Notebook LCDs range in size from 10.6 inches (diagonal) to 20 inches; display size is a key factor in the laptop's overall weight. For comfortable viewing at the preferred Windows resolution of 1,024x768, most people like 14.1-inch or larger LCDs.

The ultraportable Fujitsu LifeBook P1510 (left) has one of the smallest screens--just 8.9 inches--in order to accommodate its feather-light 1kg weight. The giant 17-inch Apple PowerBook (right), on the other hand, has the biggest notebook screen we've ever seen.


Notebook LCDs once varied widely in brightness, color, and sharpness, but today, you'll find much better quality across the board. Unfortunately, when it comes to LCDs, the specs reveal little about actual picture quality, so if you're picky about screens, compare some at your local dealer.

What types of drives do I need?

First, decide how big of a hard drive you need; this will depend on how much data you store. After that, determine what you'll use your notebook for. Will you be tackling the most basic computing tasks, or do you worship Scorcese and plan to make your own DVD movies?

Find out more about:>

Drives: Hard drive | CD and DVD drives | Swappable vs. fixed drives |  
External drives


Hard driveHard drive
Hard drive
A notebook hard drive removed from the system.
This magnetic disk provides you with space to save programs and files indefinitely--or at least for the life of the drive. Notebook hard drives can provide up to 120GB of storage, but these giant drives cost hundreds of dollars more than the default 60GB to 80GB notebook drives. The 60GB to 80GB drive should be sufficient, unless you store lots of music and movies or tons of pictures. Be warned that capacity alone does not make a good hard drive. The hard disk's rotational speed also makes a big difference; a 7,200rpm notebook disk delivers significantly faster performance than a 5,400rpm model. The faster the disk spins, the better your notebook will perform overall.

CD and DVD drivesCD and DVD drives
CD and DVD drives
Unless you're going budget, don't settle for anything less than a CD-RW drive.
Most notebooks, even budget systems, now include a CD-RW/DVD drive (either built in to the laptop or external and connected via USB) for burning discs and watching movies on the road. Some higher-end notebooks offer DVD burners, which let you store large amounts of information on one disc; double-layer DVD burners can pack even more data on a single disc. But unless you need to store huge files, such as movies, you may not need these more expensive DVD-RW drives.

Swappable vs. fixedSwappable vs. fixed
Swappable drives
Here is a media module slipping into a swappable drive. Fixed drives won't let you remove the module.
The least expensive notebooks come with fixed (built-in) drives. In other words, if you buy your notebook with a fixed DVD-ROM, you're stuck with that drive. A swappable drive bay, on the other hand, gives you optimum flexibility. For instance, you can pull out the DVD-ROM drive and swap in a combo DVD/CD-RW drive or even a second battery. We recommend going with a swappable bay if you can afford it. Keep in mind, however, that the smallest and lightest ultraportable notebooks may include neither fixed nor swappable optical drives, relying instead on external USB drives.

External drivesExternal drives
External drives
This is an external drive tethered to a Sony notebook.
External drives--storage and media-burning options that hook up to your notebook via cable--come in many shapes and sizes. Most of these drives connect to your notebook via a USB or FireWire cable. Drive choices include external floppy, CD-ROM, combo DVD/CD-RW, DVD-ROM, DVD-RW, hard drive, and others. There are also smaller external drives, called thumbdrives, that plug directly into your USB connector sans cable. These little drives are brilliant for transferring small amounts of data between notebooks or between notebooks and PCs, and they're much more convenient than burning data onto CD. Many notebook users don't need external drives, but there are scenarios that require them. For instance, if you buy a tiny ultraportable that lacks a built-in CD-ROM drive, make sure you get an external one so that you can load software.

What do I need to stay connected?

To send and receive email, browse the Web, and share files or printers, your notebook must be able to connect to a network or the Internet. This is usually done via a modem, an Ethernet hookup, or a wireless connection (either WLAN or WWAN). But your notebook has additional connectivity needs, too. Notebooks include a variety of ports, or connectors that physically link to and communicate with different kinds of equipment, including digital cameras and external monitors.

If you can't find the port you want, you can usually buy a port replicator or a docking station that adds connectors. These notebook-expansion options tend to be pricey, however, so you're generally better off buying a notebook that has everything that you'll need out of the box. Find out about each type of connection below.


Find out more about:

Get connected: PC Cards vs. mini-PCI | Networking options
| Other ports and connectors


PC Cards vs. mini-PCIPC Cards vs. ExpressCard
The PC Card, a credit card-shaped device that plugs into a slot on your notebook, can provide a number of connection types--modems, USB connections (say, for your digital camcorder), and wireless WAN radios are all available in PC Card form. PC Cards are handy because they're easy to upgrade and because you can buy third-party PC Card solutions after you purchase your notebooks. However, most notebooks come with only one or two Type II PC Card slots, forcing you to limit the number of PC Cards you can add.

Proxim Orinioco World PC Card Netgear WAB 501 dual-band wireless adapter
The Proxim Orinioco World PC Card (left) and the Netgear WAB 501 dual-band wireless adapter (right) are two examples of PC Card wireless adapters with antennae that extend beyond the edge of the notebook.


ExpressCards are the next generation of the PC Card. Smaller than existing PC Cards, ExpressCards promise data-transfer rates that are twice as fast, which means the cards can be used for high-bandwidth interfaces, such as Gigabit Ethernet ports and HDTV tuners. The standard is still relatively new, so there aren't many ExpressCard modules on the market today; however, most current laptops include an ExpressCard slot for future use. If you know you'll want to add some of these high-bandwidth functions to your laptop after you buy it, consider a system that supports the new standard.
Wireless antennae and radiosNetworking options
Though the standard is being phased out, most notebooks still come with a 56Kbps-modem (RJ-11) connection, and virtually all include Ethernet (RJ-45) or even faster Gigabit Ethernet connections. Almost all notebooks also include built-in antennas for wireless networking (802.11, or Wi-Fi) so that you can access wireless hot spots. If you choose a notebook with networking built in, consult our wireless network buying guide to learn the difference between the networking standards that are currently on the market, including 802.11a, 802.11b, and 802.11g.

If your travels regularly take you beyond the reach of Wi-Fi hot spots, you may want to consider spending a little extra for a notebook with a built-in WWAN card. These systems let you tap in to a cellular provider's data network. They can be incredibly useful when connectivity is spotty, but the technology has its downsides: data plans still tend to be pricey; throughput speeds, while improving, are still slower than most high-speed Internet; and your built-in cellular card can work with only one cellular provider.

Depending on the model you choose, you may also have the option (often for an additional cost) of ordering a Bluetooth adapter in your laptop. This will let you connect your laptop to other Bluetooth-enabled devices (such as a printer, a cell phone, or a PDA) that are in close range.

If your notebook doesn't include any of the above network adapters, it's fairly easy to find PC Cards that get the job done.

Other ports and connectors
Other ports and connectorsOther ports and connectors
Most notebooks have a VGA port for an external monitor, Ethernet and modem jacks, headphone and microphone jacks, and two to three (or more) USB ports for connecting an external keyboard and mouse, drives, digital cameras, and MP3 players. For home use, you may want any variety of A/V connections, such as S-Video, DVI, or S/PDIF output, and a FireWire port for capturing and editing digital video or hooking up an external storage drive.

What accessories do I need?

If you haven't accessorized your notebook, you haven't lived. Here are some of the best ways to do it.

Find out more about:

Accessories: Docking station or port replicator | Laptop bag | Extra battery |  
External drives | Mouse and keyboard


Docking station or port replicatorDocking station or port replicator
Docking station or port replicator
IBM's port replicator works for many different ThinkPad notebooks.
A docking station contains a mixture of ports, slots, drive bays, and security features, and it usually attaches to the notebook from underneath. Docking stations come in a variety of shapes, ranging from the same size as your notebook, which is often referred to as a media slice, to much bigger--some stick out five inches past the back of your notebook. As the name implies, a docking station is where you park your notebook when you get back to the office, giving you easy access to your network, along with a bigger monitor, a regular keyboard, additional storage devices, and the convenience of leaving cables plugged in when you walk away from your desk.

A port replicator, on the other hand, is a smaller, stripped-down version of a docking station that mainly features--as you might guess--ports, such as USB or S-Video. A port replicator can range from the size of a box of toothpaste to just shy of docking-station stature. When you're on the road, a port replicator is a convenient way to increase your connectivity.


Laptop bagLaptop bag
Laptop bag
A solid notebook carrying case is worth the extra money.
You're about to drop a couple grand or more on a laptop, and the last thing you want to do is spend even more money on a carrying case. So, you save a few bucks by going with the manufacturer's basic case. But basic bags often lack a padded shoulder strap or internal pockets. You'll be kicking yourself soon when your nine-pound load is cutting a groove into your shoulder and all of your accessories come tumbling out of your bag in a tangled mess. Dig into your wallet for a sturdy, comfortable carrying case, and your shoulder will thank you. Look for padded shoulder straps, reinforced corners, and specialized compartments designed to hold the AC adapter, the extra batteries, and so on.

Extra batteryExtra battery
Extra battery
The Compaq Evo N410c features two extra batteries.
If you do even a modest amount of traveling, we recommend getting the largest battery available for your model--or, if you're wary of the extra bulk that a larger battery entails, get a second battery. They range from S$200 to S$400, and they are well worth the money if you plan to regularly spend more than two to three hours away from a wall outlet. Next time you're trapped on the tarmac working away on your laptop and your primary battery is about to die, you'll be glad to have that second cell. If you rarely travel with your notebook, however, and your laptop is pretty much always plugged in, don't bother with a second battery.

External drivesExternal drives
External drives
This is an external drive hooked via a cable to a Sony notebook.
External drives--storage and media-burning options that hook up to your notebook via cable--can be a pain to carry around and hook up, plus they can be pricey. You're generally better off buying a notebook that has everything you need out of the box. Nevertheless, external drives are sometimes required. If, for instance, you buy an ultraportable that lacks a built-in CD-ROM drive, make sure you get an external drive so that you can load software. Types of external drives include CD-ROM, CD-RW, combo DVD/CD-RW, DVD-rewritable, hard drives, and more. No matter what notebook you buy, we strongly urge you to invest in a thumbdrive that plugs directly into your USB connector sans cable. These little drives are brilliant for transferring small amounts of data between notebooks or between notebooks and PCs, and they're much more convenient than burning data onto CD.

Mouse and keyboardMouse and keyboard
Mouse and keyboard
Wireless keyboard and mouse from IBM.
Working for hours with just a pointing stick or a touch pad can take a toll on your hand, wrist, and forearm. To save yourself some wear and tear, invest in a small travel mouse. These can cost little, they usually hook up via USB, and they're very easy to tote. The same advice applies to typing for hours on your notebook's keyboard. If you plant your notebook on your desk when you work, hook up a USB keyboard and relieve your wrists. If you prefer working without wires, get a wireless mouse and keyboard.