Advertisement

--------------------------------------------------------------
This story was printed from CNET Asia.
--------------------------------------------------------------
Flashed-out: Xenon vs. LED

By Damian Koh, CNET Asia
28/10/2009
URL: http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/mobilephones/0,39050603,62047512,00.htm

Latest update:

Sony Ericsson Satio, Samsung Pixon12

Until camera-phones with built-in Xenon flash came onto the scene, we had to live with crappy low-current LED lights. Times have changed and imaging technologies have evolved. Image sensors on camera-phones are now able to capture images at higher sensitivity (up to ISO 1,600) settings. That helps to a certain extent, but not without adding noise to the pictures when shooting in dim-light environments. On many occasions, we still need an assisting beam of light to illuminate our subjects. That's where a built-in Xenon or LED flash comes in handy.

One of the main advantages of using LED is that it doubles as a constant light source for video recording and generally gives a more even (or softer) illumination. And instead of just one, some manufacturers even stick a pair on their imaging handsets. On the other hand, while the Xenon flash has a stronger burst of light, it cannot be used for recording videos due to its technical composition.

So which type of flash is better? Below are a series of pictures taken using some of the current camera-phones. Camera settings are left at default factory settings with only forced flash enabled. We'll leave you to make your own judgment as to which is better.

Note: The pictures in this article were taken in a controlled Lab environment. You can click on the links to download the full-resolution images.

Phones with Xenon flash | Phones with LED flash



Phones with Xenon flash



LG Renoir KC910
(Download)
 

LG Viewty KU990
(Download)



Motorola Zine ZN5
(Download)
 

Nokia 6220 classic
(Download)



Nokia N82
(Download)
 

Samsung SGH-G810
(Download)



Samsung Pixon12
(Download)
 

Sony Ericsson K850i Cyber-shot
(Download)


Sony Ericsson C905 Cyber-shot
(Download)
 

Sony Ericsson Satio
(Download)

 

Phones with Xenon flash | Phones with LED flash



Phones with LED flash



LG Arena (KM900)
(Download)

LG Secret (KF750)
(Download)



LG Prada II
(Download)

LG Crystal (GD900)
(Download)



LG Viewty Smart (GC900)
(Download)

Nokia 5800 XpressMusic
(Download)



Nokia N85
(Download)

Nokia N95 (8GB)
(Download)


Nokia N96
(Download)

Nokia E75
(Download)


Nokia N97
(Download)

Nokia N86
(Download)


Samsung Innov8 (i8510)
(Download)

Samsung Pixon (M8800)
(Download)


Samsung Ultra Touch (S8300)
(Download)

Samsung Jet
(Download)


Samsung i8910 HD
(Download)

Sony Ericsson C902 Cyber-shot
(Download)


Sony Ericsson K770i Cyber-shot
(Download)

Sony Ericsson W995 Walkman
(Download)