Advertisement

--------------------------------------------------------------
This story was printed from CNET Asia.
--------------------------------------------------------------
CNET's quick guide to Bluetooth headsets

By CNET staff
24/06/2005
URL: http://asia.cnet.com/digitalliving/tips/0,3800004921,39238843,00.htm

Booms Booms
Check out these headsets with extendable boom mikes.
No booms No booms
These headsets do without the boom mike.
Battery chart Battery chart
Compare the battery life of each headset.
Bluetooth phones Bluetooth phones
Find out which models have this feature.
If you think your choice of cell phones is already too extensive, choosing a headset can be just as bewildering. With so many styles available, headsets are quickly becoming fashion accessories in their own right. And as their use proliferates, especially with the advent of hands-free legislation for drivers, you now can go far beyond clunky, tangle-prone wired headsets. Bluetooth headsets, which offer a convenient and user-friendly wireless connection between a headset and a Bluetooth-enabled cell phone, are now an "in" feature for frequent gabbers. But until recently, there weren't enough capable phones to match the wide array of headsets. Fortunately, those numbers are beginning to even out, and you can even buy adapters that let you use a headset with a non-Bluetooth phone.

To help you find the best fit, CNET's editors have compared several models on the market today and tested the headsets with a variety of phones from several manufacturers.


What's in a name?
In case you were wondering, Bluetooth gets its name from a 10th-century Danish king, Harald Blatand (or Bluetooth) who unified Denmark, Norway, and Sweden. According to legend, he had an affinity for teeth-staining blueberries. Oh, and the logo combines the runic alphabetic characters for H and B.

What is it?
Bluetooth is probably the most misunderstood child born in the wireless age. Beyond its oddball name, what it can do and how it works isn't exactly common knowledge. IDC now estimates there will be more than 100 million Bluetooth devices worldwide by the end of the year, and In-Stat/MDR expects a compound annual growth rate of 60 percent from 2003 to 2008. Truly, you now can find Bluetooth in an array of products: wireless phones, PCs, cameras, GPS devices, handhelds, and even cars.

While it may sound complicated, Bluetooth works in a simple manner. First developed by Ericsson, then formalized in 1999, it provides a way for different devices to communicate with each other by sending data via a secure, low-cost short-range radio frequency. Using the technology, cell phones can talk to headsets, PCs can talk to printers or keyboards, and handhelds can talk to each other without any wires. Up to seven connections can be made at one time, at a speed of 1Mbps. But even that's not the whole story. With the introduction of the Bluetooth-capable 2004 Toyota Prius and Lexus S430, drivers now can use their cell phone via the car's audio system and onboard navigation screen. All that's needed for any two Bluetooth-enabled devices to work is for them to be paired--normally, a hassle-free "handshaking" process for establishing a connection that takes seconds and can be found in most wireless connectivity menus.

While it may resemble Wi-Fi in its use of the same frequency range (the 2.45GHz band), the similarities stop there. Bluetooth covers one-fifth the total range of Wi-Fi, and Wi-Fi requires more-expensive hardware and reaches greater distances. Additionally, Bluetooth lets two devices communicate with each other while Wi-Fi establishes a wireless network.

Pairing up
Before you start talking, you do need to know a few facts. Bluetooth has a range of 30 feet (10 meters), and the devices in question must use compatible versions of Bluetooth. The majority of products currently in the marketplace work on Bluetooth 1.1. (Two previous versions, 1.0 and 1.0B, were plagued with compatibility issues and have since been discontinued.) The Bluetooth Special Interest Group (SIG), a trade association and development group, is releasing newer versions that promise several upgrades and backward compatibility. The most recent release, Bluetooth 1.2, includes the addition of an anonymity mode, which masks the hardware address of the device to protect from identity snooping and tracking, and adaptive frequency hopping, which cuts interference by avoiding crowded frequencies. And set for release possibly by the end of the year is Bluetooth 2.0. Among its expected enhancements are narrowband channels, which will enable messages to be broadcast to a high number of devices without the pairing process, and higher connection speeds of up to 12Mbps.

Be secure
As with any wireless device, Bluetooth has some some minor security concerns. The SIG has admitted that bluebugging, where a hacker secretly accesses a phone's commands (such as eavesdropping on conversations), and bluesnarfing, where a hacker can access a phone's data--such as the contacts--are possible, yet the group downplays both actions. While they work through Bluetooth, they also require the hacker to use a PC and to be within range of the victim. Still, Nokia and Sony have said these issues affect only older handsets that are available mainly outside of the United States, and Nokia is promising a software upgrade. To help combat both, Bluetooth devices can be locked with a code or simply turned off or put in Hidden mode when not in use. Another concern, depending on how you look at it, is bluejacking. This involves creating an often flirtatious introductory message, then sending it to another Bluetooth-discoverable phone nearby as a text message, only you can't get charged for it as you would a typical text message sent over a wireless data network.

Booms
If you favor the traditional headset look with a microphone that arches toward your mouth, a model with a boom might be the best fit. Most models use a standard ear clip, but others clamp on in alternative ways. Just be warned you may wind up looking like a pop star in concert on a good day and a professional telemarketer on a bad day.

1.  Jabra FreeSpeak BT250
 
CNETAsia rating: 8.3 out of 10
The good:  Comfortable; impressive volume and clarity; large buttons.
The bad:  Two-piece charger set.
The bottom line: You wind up looking a bit like a cyborg while wearing the Jabra, but this headset is a winner. The high volume and clarity makes it easy to forget you're even using it, while the unique, behind-the-ear design and rotating earpiece create a comfortable fit.
2.  Motorola HS850
 
CNETAsia rating: 7 out of 10
The good:  Comfortable fit; attractive design; decent sound quality.
The bad:  Hard-to-press buttons; somewhat loose on the ear.
The bottom line: The Motorola HS850 offers Bluetooth fans a stylish, well-performing headset that you won't mind wearing.

No booms
If looking like a telemarketer isn't your thing, consider these unique boomless headsets, where the microphone is located on the earpiece. Sitting just on the ear or even wrapping behind it, the models may look a little odd when they're on. All headsets paired with each of the phones we used in our tests.

1.  Sony Ericsson HBH-65
 
The good:  Featherweight; comfortable fit; large buttons; uses same charger as Sony Ericsson phones.
The bad:  Weak signal; inflexible ear loop.
The bottom line: Clad in blue and silver, the rectangular Sony Ericsson is so light we hardly felt it at all. That said, the ear loop is mostly plastic and snaps off easily. Sound quality was mixed as well. While we could hear callers easily, the signal cut out a few times.
2.  Nokia Clip-On HS-3W
 
The good:  Easy to use; good outgoing sound; uses same charger as Nokia cell phones.
The bad:  Buttons hard to press; uses wires; tinny incoming sound.
The bottom line: The bizarrely designed Nokia uses a wire to connect a normal earbud with a radio pod, which made us wonder: what's the point of a wired headset if you have Bluetooth? Not only does the wire get tangled easily, but the comfort level is no different from a standard cell phone headset's. Call quality was generally fine, but callers sounded a bit metallic.
3.  Jabra BT110
 
The good:  Excellent sound quality.
The bad:  Uninspired design; controls take some getting used to.
The bottom line: As a lower-range alternative to Jabra's FreeSpeak BT250, the Jabra BT110 has the power to bring Bluetooth to the masses. To keep the headset affordable, Jabra uses a standard AA battery, but the resulting design isn't the best. The bulbous battery compartment makes the BT110 seem somewhat lopsided, and while the BT110 is comfortable, we don't particularly care for how it looks on the ear. The controls also take some acclimation. Fortunately, Jabra doesn't compromise sound quality for economy. Pairing takes a few seconds, and conversations are clear.
4.  Jabra BT800
 
CNETAsia rating: 8 out of 10
The good:  LCD screen shows caller ID; solid call quality; comfortable fit; vibrate mode.
The bad:  Cumbersome pairing process.
The bottom line: While all Bluetooth headsets offer basic hands-free operation, the Jabra BT800 takes it a step further. Through a tiny rectangular LCD screen, BT800 users can view caller ID information and browse through a Recent Calls list using only the headset. It's an outstanding and useful addition that works as advertised, and we also appreciate the vibrate mode and the choice of ring tones. With a design different than most Jabra models, the BT800 is nonetheless comfortable. Call quality is admirable as well, but the pairing process for cell phones could be improved.

Battery life

Battery life can vary widely. Though the rated average talk time is more than five hours, some manufacturers promise much longer. Likewise, rated standby times can range from less than a week to almost a month. We put the headsets through their paces to find their actual standby battery life.
  Rated talk time
(in hours)
Rated standby time
(in days)
Actual standby time
(in days)
Jabra FreeSpeak BT250
Jabra FreeSpeak BT250
8 10 11.5
Motorola HS850
Logitech Mobile Bluetooth headset
8 8.3 4.2
Nokia Clip-On HS-3W
Nokia Clip-On HS-3W
4 4.2 4.5
Sony Ericsson Bluetooth headset HBH-65
Sony Ericsson Bluetooth headset HBH-65
2.5 3 2.75
Jabra BT110 Bluetooth headset
Jabra BT110 Bluetooth headset
15 N/A N/A
Jabra BT800
Jabra BT800
6 5 5