Clash of the titans
By Aloysius Choong
01/10/2003
URL: http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/mobilephones/0,39050603,39153191,00.htm
Handheld heavies Palm and Sony shared the honors on an eventful Wednesday that saw
a whopping six PDAs launched.
Despite being fierce rivals, there were parallels between the two Palm OS licensees,
as each unveiled a high-end connected model, a mid-range executive offering,
as well as a budget entry for first-time users.
Todd Bradley, president and chief executive of Palm Solutions Group, began
the day with a keynote on Convergence 101 at the iX 2003 conference in Singapore,
before unveiling his new products in front of reporters here. But Sony nearly stole the show later with the announcement of the ultraslick CLIE PEG-UX50's Asian availability.
"Whatever you compare handhelds to, from a market perspective, there is
still enormous amounts of growth that we can all participate in," said
Bradley, dispelling suggestions that the handheld market is dying. He argued
that PDAs are still in a "very evolving stage" and that there were
opportunities in various audience segments and countries such as China and India.
Palm is hoping that its three new models--two Tungstens and a Zire--will fill
part of that demand. It will, however, face more than a bit of competition from
Sony's UX50 and all-new TJ series--officially announced for the first
time globally.
| Match-up |
Palm's
entry |
Sony's pitch |
| Featherweight
feud: Electronic organizers |
|
|
Pricing |
S$200 (US$116) |
S$369
(US$214) |
| Vital
stats |
Palm
OS 5.2.1; 126MHz processor; 8MB memory; monochrome display. |
Palm
OS 5.2; ARM-compliant 200MHz processor; 16MB memory; 65,536-color
display. |
| Our
thoughts |
The
Palm Zire 21 improves upon the plain ol' Zire with a faster
processor and more memory. However, we can't help but bemoan
its lackadaisical monochrome, non-backlit screen. The S$369
TJ25 offers a pretty 16-bit color display with a faster processor,
more memory, and a more stylish exterior than the Zire 21, but
may in turn be outshone by the music-playing Palm Tungsten E.
|
|
Dressed to kill: Multimedia for
execs |
|
|
Pricing |
S$378 (US$219) |
S$489
(US$283) |
| Vital
stats |
Texas
Instruments 126MHz ARM processor; 32MB memory. |
Palm
OS 5.2; ARM-compliant 200MHz processor; 32MB memory; 65,536-color
display; MP3 playback. |
| Our
thoughts |
Both
classy and elegant devices, the Palm Tungsten E and Sony CLIE
PEG-TJ35 are pitched at the executive crowd. There aren't any
frills to speak of--no fancy Bluetooth or camera features, but
for a sub-S$500 price tag, you get a presentable gadget for
listening to music and getting your life organized. The S$378
Tungsten E hits the sweet spot as far as pricing is concerned,
and looks a strong sell against both TJs.
|
| No
limits: Connectivity and more |
|
|
Pricing |
S$718 (US$416) |
S$1,189
(US$688) |
| Vital
stats |
Palm
OS 5.2.1; Intel XScale 400MHz processor; 64MB memory; Bluetooth;
large, 320x480-pixel display. |
Palm
OS 5.2; Sony Handheld Engine processor; 64MB memory; integrated
digital camera; Wi-Fi; Bluetooth; full QWERTY keyboard.. |
| Our
thoughts |
Sony,
style-meister extraordinaire, outdoes even itself with the UX50,
a swiveling clamshell with a landscape display, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi
and an integrated digital camera. The Palm's slider mechanism
was cool yesterday but is now looking a tad dated with the third
iteration of the Tungsten T. But when it comes down to getting
the job done, the Bluetooth-enabled T3 notches up a CNET Editors'
Choice-winning performance.
|
|
|