Top 5 polyphonic phones
By Aloysius Choong
10/01/2002
URL: http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/mobilephones/0,39050603,39010035,00.htm
Just as PC-emitted beeps and clicks have given way to sound cards and digitized
music in desktops, polyphony is the mobile phone's industry answer to more musical ringtones. With the ability to play different instruments simultaneously, polyphonic phones may eventually replace the shrill ringing sounds of most handsets today. When that happens, remember these five phones that started it all.
|
 |
1. |
Samsung
SGH-N620
We liked what we've heard from the
Samsung SGH-N620. It's the only phone on the market capable of 16 simultaneous
sounds, and the speaker delivers the music crisply. The games employ convincing sound effects, such as the explosion of alien ships when we shoot them down. Coupled with "force
feedback", this makes for an engaging experience. The phone comes with a
number of polyphonic ringtones to keep us interested for a while. But for
further downloads, we'll have to wait and see what Samsung comes up
with.
Review
| See
Comparison Chart | Rate
This
|
|
|
|
2. |
Alcatel
One Touch 511
The Alcatel OT511 was the first of the lot, at least in Singapore. Capable of eight simultaneous
sounds including percussion, its ringtone playback certainly impressed us. However,
the speaker does sound a tad muffled. To Alcatel's credit, so far the OT511 is the only handset to launch with polyphonic ringtone downloads from a mobile operator. The
sound effects also add more atmosphere to the two games developed by Infogrames.
Review
| See
Comparison Chart | Rate
This | Check
Latest Price |
|
|
 |
3. |
Trium
Eclipse
With any luck, we'll get to see this
excellent handset in the shops here. Although capable of only three simultaneous
sounds, we think the quality of the speaker makes up for it. Loud and clear,
it complements the Rayman games that come with the handset. If the Eclipse
is anything to go by, the upcoming polyphonic Trium twins--the Mistral and
the Odyssey--will be worth a listen.
Review
| See
Comparison Chart | Rate
This |
|
|
|
4. |
Panasonic
GD75
While not a spectacular polyphonic performer, this attractive number may
offer the first taste of mobile ringtone music for some. You just might be able
to get it for less than S$150 at some shops. The GD75 is a sign that polyphony is not a luxury feature, and can thus be widely implemented. The phone speaker is average,
while only three layers of polyphonic tones are available. Percussion
effects such as drum beats are not supported.
Review
| See
Comparison Chart | Rate
This | Check
Latest Price |
|
|
|
5. |
Panasonic
GD95
The Panasonic GD95 is similar to the GD75, with the exception of a few features such as the big screen. As a polyphonic phone, though, we think it loses out to its brethren on the issue of price. From now until end January, Panasonic users can download up
to three free ringtones from the Panasonic
Web site. The site works well enough as a platform, but there are only
nine tunes available, including some off-season Yuletide ditties.
Review
| See
Comparison Chart | Rate
This | Check
Latest Price |
|