CNET's quick guide to surround formats
By Steve Guttenberg, CNET.com
02/08/2005
URL: http://asia.cnet.com/reviews/home_av/others/0,39037627,39211880,00.htm
|
Dolby formats From Dolby
Headphone to Dolby Digital, here's the inside scoop on the king of
surround. |
 |
|
DTS formats The
second-most-popular surround company has its own lineup of formats, including
Neo:6 and a DVD-Audio competitor. |
 |
|
DVD-Audio, SACD, and
THX Take a brief look at the two warring high-resolution music
formats; plus, a little on the THX-certification program. |
 |
From Edison's
first wax-cylinder machine to the mid-1950s, home audio was always mono. Stereo
took off in the '60s, and the first surround format to take hold and flourish
was Dolby Surround in 1982. Dolby Surround is a matrix format; that is,
its surround effects are encoded in two stereo channels. Many of today's
surround formats are discrete and feature six separate tracks.
Some DVDs feature multiple surround formats--for example, Dolby
Surround, Dolby Digital, and DTS--on a single disc. This brings up another angle
to the surround story; to enjoy the full sound potential of, say, a
DTS-ES-encoded DVD, you need a receiver that processes DTS-ES. In other words,
formats exist in both software and hardware. Other formats, such as Dolby Pro
Logic II and DTS Neo:6, are found only on hardware--receivers, HTIBs, DVD
players, and so on--and are applied to processing software or music sources,
such as CDs, DVDs, MP3 files, and radio.
When we designate the maximum
number of speakers/channels for each format, such as 5.1 or 6.1, we're referring
to the number of front, center, rear, and possibly center-rear speakers (the
.1 refers to the subwoofer) that the format can use. Stereo, a.k.a. 2.0,
is a two-channel format. Check out the diagram below to see how they are set up
in a room. Note that even though 7.1 systems use two back-surround speakers, the
same channel of information goes to both of them.

Dolby Formats
 |
 |
Dolby
Digital
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 5.1 |
Upside:
Dolby Digital is the near-universal surround format.
Downside:
Sound quality, while acceptable for movies, is a far cry from
ultrahigh-resolution formats such as DVD-Audio and Super Audio CD (SACD).
Forecast: It is, and will likely
remain, the preeminent surround format.
Dolby Digital is the most popular surround format and can be found
on virtually every DVD, including almost all DVD music discs, and many HDTV
programs. Pretty much every A/V receiver and HTIB on the market features Dolby
Digital processing.
 |
 |
Dolby
Pro Logic II
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 5.1 |
Upside: Pro Logic
II can be found on most new receivers and HTIBs.
Downside:
None.
Forecast: This very popular format is in for
the long haul.
First, Pro Logic II isn't one of those synthetic "jazz club" and
"stadium" modes and doesn't add synthesized reverberation or echoes. It's a
hardware-based format that's compatible with all stereo and matrix-encoded
surround software. Pro Logic II is an update of the original Pro Logic and can
be used to freshen up Dolby Surround-encoded videotapes and DVDs. It also works
wonders with stereo CDs and radio broadcasts.
 |
 |
Dolby
Digital EX
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 7.1 |
Upside: Creates a
more spacious and focused surround effect than 5.1 surround.
Downside: Scarce
availability of EX-encoded DVDs; requires a Dolby EX receiver and additional
speaker(s); difficult to implement in a room where the prime listening position
is located near a wall.
Forecast: Because of EX's downsides, interest
in the format will likely remain low.
Dolby EX is a 6.1-channel format, adding one (or two) rear
center-surround channel speakers to the standard 5.1 array. EX can deliver more
enveloping surround effects than standard Dolby Digital. EX processing can be
used to improve the sound of regular Dolby Digital-encoded DVDs. Unlike DTS ES,
Dolby EX features an extra rear channel that's matrix rather than discrete.
That's why ES can provide a more precise location for the rear-effects
soundstage.
 |
 |
Dolby
Digital Plus 
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 13.1 |
Upside: Improved surround sound performance with high data rates and increased audio channels; Backward compatible with existing Dolby Digital decoders.
Downside: Requires new HDMI/FireWire interface and additional speakers.
Forecast: Elected by the DVD forum, this latest product from Dolby Laboratory will be the standard feature for future High-Definition materials.
An extension of Dolby Digital (DD), the Dolby Digital Plus (DD+) has been chosen as the mandatory surround format for Blu-ray and HD-DVD. It supports up to 13.1 discreet channels with a maximum data rate of 6Mbps. To support the high data rate, HDMI and IEEE1394 (FireWire) have been selected as the new digital interface for DD+ connectivity. The latest Dolby format is backward compatible with existing DD decoders via down-mixing capability and SPDIF digital audio output. DD+ will be available from late 2005.
 |
 |
Dolby
Headphone
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 2.0 |
Upside: Simulated
surround over conventional headphones.
Downside:
Headphone surround isn't nearly as impressive as sound over speakers.
Forecast: The format is just now starting to
gain some momentum, and we expect more and more receivers and HDTVs to feature
Dolby Headphone processing.
Dolby Headphone synthesizes five-channel surround effects over any
brand of headphone. It offers up to three processing "flavors" that simulate
rooms of varying sizes and acoustics. While Dolby Headphone technology offers a
substantially more spacious sound compared to the standard stereo headphone
experience, it does not synthesize quasisurround from conventional stereo
sources such as CDs, MP3s, or FM radio. Right now, you'll find Dolby Headphone
processing on the latest generation of higher-end receivers, but we expect the
feature will soon find its way onto more moderately priced
components.
DTS Formats
 |
 |
DTS
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 5.1 |
Upside: Some
audiophiles feel that DTS-encoded DVDs offer better sound than those with Dolby
Digital.
Downside:
Compared to Dolby Digital, DTS encoding is found on relatively few
DVDs.
Forecast: We'll see more and more DTS-encoded
DVDs.
DTS is an alternative to standard Dolby Digital. DTS uses less
compression than Dolby, and some audiophiles believe it produces richer bass and
greater dynamics. Virtually all receivers and home-theater systems include DTS
processing.
 |
 |
DTS
Neo:6
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 7.1 |
Upside: Neo:6
provides up to six full-band channels of matrix decoding from stereo matrix
material.
Downside:
None.
Forecast: This format will
last.
It's similar to Dolby Pro Logic II, but Neo:6 produces up to 6.1
channels of surround vs. PLII's max of 5.1. You can use two rear-center speakers
and bring the speaker tally up to 7.1. Like its rival Dolby format, Neo:6 is
fully compatible with all stereo sources.
 |
 |
DTS
ES
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 7.1 |
Upside: More
enveloping surround effects than standard 5.1 surround.
Downside:
Requires a receiver with ES processing; difficult to implement in rooms
where the prime listening position (couch or chair) is located near a wall;
ES-encoded DVDs remain scarce.
Forecast: Because of these downsides,
interest in ES will likely remain low.
ES adds one (or two) rear-center-surround channel speakers to the
standard 5.1 array and can deliver more enveloping surround effects than
standard Dolby or DTS. Unlike EX, Dolby's matrix, 6.1-channel format, DTS ES
offers a fully discrete back channel for more precise localization and imaging.
But that advantage over Dolby EX holds for only DTS ES-encoded DVDs;
currently, a mere handful of titles is available. To utilize this format, you'll
need an ES-capable receiver.
 |
 |
DTS
HD 
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: Unlimited |
Upside: Lossless format for the purist. Backward compatible with existing DTS decoders.
Downside:
Optional surround sound format for Blu-ray and HD-DVD.
Forecast: Technically superior compared to its Dolby counterpart, DTS-HD will be a highly sought-after surround sound format for audiophiles.
DTS HD, previously know as DTS++, is DTS's answer to its rival surround sound format. It supports unlimited number of surround sound channels and delivers audio quality at bit rates extending from DTS digital surround to lossless. Although technically superior over its Dolby counterpart, DTS HD is selected only as an optional surround sound format for Blu-ray and HD-DVD. The new DTS format is backward compatible with existing DTS decoders and supports down-mixing function for converting DTS HD signal to 5.1 and stereo formats.
 |
 |
DTS
96/24
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 5.1 |
Upside:
Comparable to DVD-Audio quality but doesn't require a DVD-Audio player; six
discrete channels; full video capability; DTS 96/24 discs will play on any DVD
player.
Downside: Limited
software availability; requires receivers with DTS 96/24 processing.
Forecast: DTS 96/24 will coexist with DVD-A
but won't likely become a mainstream format.
DTS 96/24 is similar to DVD-Audio in that it provides
high-resolution 96/24 5.1-channel sound, but it also offers full-motion video
capability (DVD-A has only limited video capacity). Another advantage is that
you don't need to buy a new DVD-Audio player; the DTS 96/24 signal can be fed by
any DVD player via a single digital cable to DTS processors in the receiver. To
get the best sound, you need a receiver with up-to-the-minute DTS 96/24
processors.
DVD-Audio, SACD, and THX
 |
 |
DVD-Audio
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 5.1 |
Upside: Better
sound quality than CD; discs usually have surround and stereo mixes; some titles
contain multimedia capabilities, photo galleries, and occasional video.
Downside: Limited
selection of titles currently available.
Forecast: Universal Super Audio
CD/DVD-Audio/Video players will likely ensure the survival of this
format.
DVD-A offers 1,000 times the resolution of CD and can deliver up
to six channels of ultrahigh-resolution sound. But to access those tracks, you
need a DVD-Audio player, although almost all DVD-A discs have lower-quality
Dolby Digital or DTS tracks that can be played by any DVD player. DVD-Audio
sound has great detail and texture, and it's more lifelike than CD. DVD-Audio
will be primarily of interest to audiophile-inclined home-theater fans. To enjoy
a DVD-A player's full sound potential, you must use a receiver equipped with
5.1-channel analog inputs and good-quality speakers.
 |
 |
Super
Audio CD
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 5.1 |
Upside: Better
sound quality than CDs; many SACD discs include multichannel and stereo
mixes.
Downside: Limited
selection of titles currently available; this is strictly an audio-only format
and lacks video capability.
Forecast: Universal machines that play Super
Audio CDs, DVD-Audio/Video discs, and CDs will eventually ensure the format's
long-term survival.
The SACD format employs a new technology dubbed Direct Stream
Digital (DSD). Proponents claim DSD is kinder and gentler to the music than CD's
Pulse Code Modulation (PCM) format. While CDs poke along with a 44.1kHz sampling
rate, DSD cranks things up to a warp-speed 2.8224MHz. This results in vastly
greater resolution, texture, and detail than CDs. Standard Super Audio CDs will
run on only SACD players, while newer hybrid SACDs will play on SACD, CD, and
DVD players. To enjoy an SACD player's surround sound, you must use a receiver
equipped with 5.1 analog inputs. A good-quality speaker system is required to
appreciate the format's potential.
 |
 |
THX
Maximum number of
speakers/channels: 7.1 |
Upside:
THX-certified systems produce a more consistent, higher-quality home-theater
experience.
Downside: Can be
found on only expensive components.
Forecast: THX's systemic approach will ensure
its long-term survival.
Not a surround format per se, THX strives to deliver
cinema-quality picture and sound to home systems via certified products such as
speakers, receivers, DVD players, and even cables. Two levels of certification
are offered: Select and Ultra 2. Select components are optimized for use in
midsized rooms of less than 2,000 cubic feet, and Ultra 2 components can
accommodate 3,000-cubic-foot rooms. Also, Ultra 2 is a 7.1-channel system,
capable of producing a more uniformly distributed surround effect throughout the
room than Dolby EX or DTS ES surround.
|