CNET's quick guide to surround formatsDVD-Audio, SACD, and THX
Upside: Better
sound quality than CD; discs usually have surround and stereo mixes; some titles
contain multimedia capabilities, photo galleries, and occasional video.
Downside: Limited
selection of titles currently available.
Forecast: Universal Super Audio
CD/DVD-Audio/Video players will likely ensure the survival of this
format. DVD-A offers 1,000 times the resolution of CD and can deliver up
to six channels of ultrahigh-resolution sound. But to access those tracks, you
need a DVD-Audio player, although almost all DVD-A discs have lower-quality
Dolby Digital or DTS tracks that can be played by any DVD player. DVD-Audio
sound has great detail and texture, and it's more lifelike than CD. DVD-Audio
will be primarily of interest to audiophile-inclined home-theater fans. To enjoy
a DVD-A player's full sound potential, you must use a receiver equipped with
5.1-channel analog inputs and good-quality speakers.
Upside: Better
sound quality than CDs; many SACD discs include multichannel and stereo
mixes.
Downside: Limited
selection of titles currently available; this is strictly an audio-only format
and lacks video capability.
Forecast: Universal machines that play Super
Audio CDs, DVD-Audio/Video discs, and CDs will eventually ensure the format's
long-term survival. The SACD format employs a new technology dubbed Direct Stream
Digital (DSD). Proponents claim DSD is kinder and gentler to the music than CD's
Pulse Code Modulation (PCM) format. While CDs poke along with a 44.1kHz sampling
rate, DSD cranks things up to a warp-speed 2.8224MHz. This results in vastly
greater resolution, texture, and detail than CDs. Standard Super Audio CDs will
run on only SACD players, while newer hybrid SACDs will play on SACD, CD, and
DVD players. To enjoy an SACD player's surround sound, you must use a receiver
equipped with 5.1 analog inputs. A good-quality speaker system is required to
appreciate the format's potential.
Upside:
THX-certified systems produce a more consistent, higher-quality home-theater
experience.
Downside: Can be
found on only expensive components.
Forecast: THX's systemic approach will ensure
its long-term survival. Not a surround format per se, THX strives to deliver
cinema-quality picture and sound to home systems via certified products such as
speakers, receivers, DVD players, and even cables. Two levels of certification
are offered: Select and Ultra 2. Select components are optimized for use in
midsized rooms of less than 2,000 cubic feet, and Ultra 2 components can
accommodate 3,000-cubic-foot rooms. Also, Ultra 2 is a 7.1-channel system,
capable of producing a more uniformly distributed surround effect throughout the
room than Dolby EX or DTS ES surround.
|
- Talkback
-







