Subscribe to this blog

The R.O.C.

From cloner haven to global heavyweight, Taiwan continues to reinvent itself

 

Jan 18, 2008 15:57

Do HTC phones actually suck?

Posted by jonathangardner
HTC, the flavor of the month from Taipei, may be pissing some people off. While the company continues to build cred for handhelds (Dopod) and handsets (big in the US in particular), I was just alerted to the fact that the emperor may actually be partly naked:

"Welcome to HTCClassAction.org. This site is intended to spread awareness about the issues with recent HTC Smartphones and PocketPCs, and gather information for a possible class action lawsuit against HTC. That class action lawsuit will be a last resort and is still far off. Hopefully, we can raise awareness and publicity high enough to convince HTC to solve these issues without a lawsuit. It has, however, now been over six months since the first affected device was released, and as of yet, HTC has done nothing."

One of the dudes behind this consumer effort said the following via email:

"HTC might be big and growing fast, but I don not a give a damn pushing this case further trying to get a solution for thousands of consumers. When profit, profit and only profit remains. Taiwanese companies will certainly loose [sic] their battle in a [sic] near future against their upcoming Chinese rivals. I am sure you know what I mean.

"Service support to consumers was never a great virtue of some Taiwanese companies as it might result in loosing [sic] face once they have to admit they could have done much better."

While we need to wait for more evidence, this is a bit troubling. Seems nearly every Taiwan hotshot company lets us down, usually for corruption. In this case, no one's saying anything's amiss at HTC in general, but some folks [via HTCClassAction.org] are ticked off about the company's device drivers delivering underwhelming performance:

"The latest SmartPhone and PocketPC devices from HTC (High Tech Computing) are supposed to be the most powerful devices on the market. And in theory, they are indeed real powerhouses of mobile technology. There's a catch though: HTC has neglected to include the necessary drivers needed for the devices to come to their full potential.

"This means our really expensive HTC phones (the TyTN II is about $700) are grossly underperforming. In fact, in many things, these devices operate even slower than HTC's (and competitors') two years older models--see the videos under navigation for demonstrations, especially the TomTom video (TyTN II vs Magician) is a terrific example."

Of course, this could just be one (or many) people getting pissy with too much time on their hands. Conversely, there could be real issues afoot. Personally, I'd have to be really infuriated to do something such as consider legal action.

Anyway, this, of course, may be a whole lot of nothing and we don't want to jump to conclusions. Possibly these are isolated incidents. I welcome the HTC folks to get in touch and help to clarify the situation. I'm not optimistic that they will, however, as in my experience Taiwan companies are not so great at issues management and external communications.

It seems the issue is at least being taken seriously by the tech media.

UK powerhouse The Register reports the following:

"Peeved HTC smartphone owners offer bounty for driver fix: A Web site is offering HTC smartphone customers a US$3,000 financial reward
if they're able to solve a series of graphics and related issues affecting the company's recent handsets, allegedly caused by missing or
poorly performing hardware drivers."

The HTCClassAction.org guys have gotten some apparently off-the-record acknowledgement of the problems from internal HTC sources. This sounds like yet another example of a befuddled local company getting slammed for an issue and being unable to offer a coordinated, satisfactory response.

Either way, let's wait and see how this pans out.

Hopefully, HTC will do the right thing and everyone will be happy. I'd hate for the world to have yet another reason not to trust Taiwan companies.

More to come
--jag


3 comments   |   Share


 


    Talkback
ceevee369 says...
I am happy and at the same time not happy to read this article.
Happy to see it here on CNET, not happy as it could have been solved upfront, sparing HTC from potential loss and contenting thousands of users with a solution, gaining extra thrust in HTC with efficient consumer response.

Being a Tytn II owner myself, I found out about this issue in October and wrote a few times to HTC which only resulted in automated reply messages. I gained knowledge on XDA finding myslelf among 1000’s of other victims.

It is seldom that consumer complaints in this Area get big awareness though this one seems to hit the boards and certainly undermines HTC’s credibility.

I just hope that HTC releases a press statement confirming this issue and offers a solution. What they do not understand and for sure under estimate is that a typical Tytn II owner is mostly having a stronger voice as he /she expects value for 700$ money. And that voice is being heard now it seems.

So, the ball is in HTC’s camp. Not Qualcomm as they only provide the components to HTC. They can approach it 3-ways: Statement and release of update . No statement and no solution or, the most typical Taiwanese solution; A sudden post of a Wm 6.1 upgrade “surprisingly” solving the issue as it never existed.
I bet on the third option.

 
 
johnchan says...
Hey Jonathan,

Nice spot there. I've got you linked on Crave. asia.cnet.com...

 
 
ceevee369 says...
John, I am glad to read that you find it a nice spot set up by Jonathan( though CNET should have spotted it months ago in my honest opinion).

Ignore my mail send to you directly. I thought that CNET did not wanted to put HTC in a bad daylight.

      Report offensive
 
 
To post comments, you need to become a member. It's FREE.



 
advertisement
 

Members With Similar Interests

 
sherriton's avatar
sherriton
Level:
 
 
 
 
Nantharuban's avatar
Nantharuban
Level:
 
 
 
 
matthewtan28's avatar
matthewtan28
Level:
 
 
 
 
zaki572's avatar
zaki572
Level:
 
 
 
 
pakcikkodi's avatar
pakcikkodi
Level: