Subscribe to this blog

The Tech Dynasty

Navigating the bamboo scaffolding of China's rapid-rising tower of technology

 

Dec 16, 2008 11:44

Shanghai woman refuses to be held captiva by tower, viral ad?

Posted by RyanM
With marketing budgets being slashed in the "new economy", low-cost/high-return word-of-mouth advertising is going to be more relevant than ever.

A new viral video spreading its way across Chinese forums shows a Shanghai woman arguing with a tow truck driver. Despite her Chevrolet Captiva's rear wheels being hitched to the tow truck, she jumps in her SUV and drives away, with tow truck in tow.



Commenters on this post, as well as the YouTube page, are quick to cry foul and call the video a fake--a staged viral ad created by Chevy to tout the hauling power of the Captiva.

Ethically I don't see anything wrong with the use of viral marketing (at least in this case). Even if it is a fake, it's a darn clever one. It's funny, it's relatable, and--fake or not--it doesn't fool the viewer by breaking any sort of trust.

So, I'm not entirely sure why commenters are dismissing the video outright simply because it might have been staged. Could it be the offense of being advertised to unwittingly? The idea that ads must be distinctly identified as such? What?

I'm curious to hear your thoughts in the comments below on the matter and on the ethics of viral marketing at large.

3 comments   |   Share


 


    Talkback
damiankoh says...
the driver of the tow truck didn't pull the handbrake when he stopped to tow the chevrolet?

 
 
montbkk says...
This really brings us to the fundamental question "if the state should protect the people from themselves"? Every citizen has the right to be stupid but do businesses have the right to profit from their stupidity?

Many there are who can not distinguish between the probable truth, the improbable and the impossible. Corporations know this and take full advantage in their advertising and business practices to profit from the weakest members of our societies.

I believe there should be clear legal limits to advertising and such "clips" as this one are clearly designed to take advantage of the culturally challenged....its a no go for me.

 
 
sevenich says...
First, I don't want to miss the point - it was FUN to watch the video. Tell me who among motorists is not mad at those often indiscrimate tow trucks? It's a menace in major Asian cities! For a moment there, I get to say "yes lady, way to go!!!"

Now as to whether the ad was a video capture of an event that is staged or not, I remember that the person who sent this video link to me never said "this is a true story" or "this really happened." I have been in Shanghai very often, and I have seldom seen tow trucks doing their thing this way. I even doubt this is in Shanghai, to be honest, as the streets are not as crowded as typical Shanghai. Many people won't even recognize the car as Chevrolet Captiva. So please.... let's not sweat out the small details... I say - bring it on! Good entertainment usually comes free!

 
 
To post comments, you need to become a member. It's FREE.



 
advertisement
 

RyanM's Contacts

 
spangaroo's avatar
spangaroo
Level:
Taiwan
 
 
 

See all contacts »

 

Members With Similar Interests

 
cvravishankar's avatar
cvravishankar
Level:
 
 
 
 
slockums's avatar
slockums
Level:
 
 
 
 
kcyjason's avatar
kcyjason
Level:
 
 
 
 
harsij200's avatar
harsij200
Level:
 
 
 
 
Nantharuban's avatar
Nantharuban
Level: