CNET Asia
 
 Print    Email     Bookmark     Share

OS X vs Vista

Security
The combat begins on horseback. Much like how the knights of yore protected a kingdom against marauding forces, our protagonists mount their trusty steeds to show the maiden just how much protection they can offer her against the outside world.

Baron Vista believes he has an edge--the layer of chain mail beneath his frilly shirt is far more durable than that of his XP predecessor. It incorporates a number of highly advanced security features designed to keep him safe from attack.

Baron Vista is hoping that his prominence in the land won't make him a highly visible and often hated target. His worry is that the loathing he has inherited from his father, Lord XP, means many subversive forces are plotting his demise.

Count OS X, by comparison, is counting on his few enemies to see him through. His armor is forged from the fires of Unix, which he hopes will keep him safe from the common viruses that plague the land.

But enough preamble--it's time for the duel. Charge!

The outcome was almost preordained. Baron Vista lies in a crumpled heap on the floor, having been unable to penetrate Count OS X's armor.

It's hardly surprising--Windows' susceptibility to hackers and malware is well-documented. If your PC is connected to the Internet, there's a good chance digital nasties are forcing their way in. If not, your PC probably has the back door wide open anyway.

Microsoft is trying, though--it has added the User Account Controls (UAC) feature, which prevents dangerous software from making changes to your PC. If Vista thinks a program could compromise its security, it'll suffer a panic attack, produce a dialogue box and tells you something bad might happen. It's effective for the most part, but the level of intrusion is infuriating. We almost hope the cybercrooks get through UAC so Microsoft has to invent a better solution.

Microsoft should be able to keep its OS safe by now, but out of the box, Vista is a sitting duck. Microsoft recommends you update its main shield, Windows Defender, every week, however with thousands of new spyware strains created every month, how can you be sure this is enough to protect your system? Virus protection is non-existent out of the box, too--you'll have to buy that separately.

Buy an Apple PC and you can be confident of safety. It ships with all communication ports closed. Native services such as FTP access, remote login and printer sharing are all switched off by default so the chances of a hacker attack are minimal to say the least. Even without all this fancy protection, nobody's bothering to make viruses for Macs anyway, so it's the best bet for digital hypochondriacs.

Score: Mac OS X-1, Windows Vista-0

Performance »

More Resources From CNET Asia

How to upgrade Windows XP to Windows Vista

Find out what you'll need to upgrade your current files and software to Windows Vista.

Notebook online auction buying guide

Looking for a good notebook deal online? We give you a few tips on how to spot a bargain and avoid common con techniques.

Fast fixes for 10 common Wi-Fi problems

If wireless network problems are leaving you befuddled, these valuable tips can help you make a better connection.

OS X vs Vista

What better way to end the age-old OS X vs Vista debate than to set the two up for a traditional Elizabethan duel? Prepare yourselves for one of the bloodiest battles your eyes hath ever seen...

advertisement
 

CNET Asia Buying Guides

Before heading to the stores,
CNET fills you in on what
you need to know to find the
perfect product match.


 


Sign up for updates!

Every fortnight, we'll teach you the latest tricks in notebooks. View sample »