advertisement
  • Search and Compare
Brand
Product Type
Interface Type
Storage type
Display
Price


  • Get updates
Get a round-up of the latest fun on-the-go, from portable audio/video players to videocams.
 Print    Email     Bookmark     Share
Advertisement
MP3 player shopping checklist
By CNET Asia staff
16/11/2006

MP3 player shopping checklist

MP3 players are getting cheaper with bigger onboard storage and wider format support. And what's more, features have been mushrooming like fungi in a wet cave. Think games, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi, personal information management, satellite radio, cameras and video playback.

These are the things we would not have normally associated with an MP3 player. But in the name of digital entertainment, convergence has forced the issue. But don't get fazed by all the mumbo jumbo. Here's the basic checkpoints to ensure you get a decent deal on something that's built to play music most of all.

Factors: Player type | Sound | Battery | Software | Music formats | Other features

Player type
If you don't need a very small, skip-free device, you're probably better off with a player that uses a cheaper form of storage. MP3 CD players leverage your CD burner and let you store the most music on the cheapest medium. Hard drive-based players contain the most music but are generally bigger in size and cost more. More memory means longer playtime, though battery life is also an important issue. For flash players we recommend looking for a flash memory unit with at least 1GB of onboard memory and an expandability slot, though it is no longer a common feature in MP3 players nowadays.



Things to consider
• What you looking for? Flash memory, a CD drive, a hard drive? Each has its own merits.
• Expandability
• Does it feature anti-skip technology?

Sound
For louder audio, go for players that have a headphone output rating of at least 10mw. Plus, do not buy an audio player with a signal-to-noise ratio of less than 85dB.



Things to consider
•  The type of headphones you intend to use (Low powered or high powered)
•  Equalizer settings to tweak the sound
• Train/silent mode to muffle the volume on public transports

Battery
Go for flash memory players if you want a model with long battery life (30 hours or more). With hard drive MP3 players, you'll end up having to charge the battery each day since they give only an average life of 15 to 20 hours. Players with removable cells are also convenient for long trips.



Things to consider
•  Battery type (removable or non-removable)
•  Battery life
• Battery recharge time
• Recharge from power outlet or USB port?

Software
Most audio players include software for synchronizing music directly to the device. However, watch out for proprietary DRM (digital rights management) software. These schemes can require the creation an encrypted copy of every song that you want to put on the player, making a generally beautifully designed hardware ugly to use.



Things to consider
•  What operating systems does it support?
•  Ripping/track tagging features
• Supports Digital Rights Management
• Other features like volume normalization and playlist support

Music formats
New portable devices should play other music formats like Windows Media Audio (WMA), Advance Audio Coding (AAC), OGG Vorbis and even high-quality Free Lossless Audio Codec (FLAC). Also check whether a player supports the playback of encrypted music. Some models won't recognize DRM-enforced files downloaded from online musical pay sites such as iTunes and Rhapsody.



Things to consider
•  Is the format supported by your computer's OS?
•  Does your software offer encoding into that particular format?
• If you change player, can the format be played on your new device?
• Supports ID3 tagging or track name labelling?
• Can the format be converted into other formats? (i.e. for archival)

Other features
Consider extras such as voice recorders, FM tuners and memory card expansion slots. For the fastest possible file transfers to a hard drive-based MP3 player, look for USB 2.0 or FireWire.



Things to consider
•  Do the added features--like FM tuners and voice recorders--take extra toll on the battery life?
•  Are the features easy to access and operate?
• Can copy media to the player without any software? (i.e. plug-and-play feature)
• Digital photo wallet feature?
• Video playback?


More resources from CNET
The truth about battery life
Where do I get music?
Get real. Battery life is probably one of the most important factors to consider before getting an portable device. James Kim tells us why.
An MP3 player's no good if there isn't any content. Here's how to get yours.
MP3 player shopping checklist
10 mistakes to avoid when buying MP3 players
Searching for the ultimate portable music soulmate? This quick-and-dirty guide will help you pick the ideal MP3 player for your needs.
Don't let your rhythm-tapping fingers click the purchase button till you check out our buying tips.